What would be so bad?

[DonnieYen]

What would be so bad if we can't draft a top QB of drafting Maryland's QB Taulia or Notre Dame's QB?

[bavarobeast]

We’ll first off the Notre Dame QB was unimpressive at the combine and second he was unimpressive at Notre Dame. He should focus on hair commercials. 

Taulia doesn’t like pressure - forces the ball and makes poor decisions. Michigan verified that last fall.

If he has time to throw and things are fine and dandy in the pocket he’s pretty good.

The QB from South Alabama is a sleeper if you want a sleeper. Carter Bradley - in 2 seasons threw for just under 6,000 yards - 47 touchdowns 19 picks.

65%  completion percentage. I have not seen him even though I live in Alabama however I hear he has got NFL talent from Alabama and Auburn sources.

🤷‍♂️ FWIW

[IrishMike]

If Jones doesn't work out we are rolling with Lock. If that doesn't work we are in prime position to draft Manning in a few years.

[cdngfan]

I’m not afraid of that. A team with as many holes as we have will DEFINITELY go into 24’ with holes unfilled. Which ones can you fill? It won’t be all of them.

And even if we draft a rookie QB in the first, 66% of the time those QBs don’t play well enough for fans to feel like they’ve found their guy.

Other positions just have a lower bar to deem a pick as “good”.

Not to mention there’s plenty of years where there’s 1 good QB available after evaluating the draft a few years later. The year DJ was drafted, unless you had the #1 pick overall, you drafted a backup. So what should a team do that needed a QB but didn’t have the 1st overall pick? Draft one anyway? Don’t draft one and try to justify why? Do you keep your job while waiting to prove your decision was right?

The QB position is unique in more ways than 4.

[lt56]

explain this obsession with Taulia Tagovailoa who is considered a Day 3 maybe even Undrafted Free Agent who didn't get a Combine Invite? Wish him luck though, maybe he ends up being the next Brock Purdy

as for Sam Hartman...HELL NO! he was a much better QB at Wake Forest but nothing but inconsistency at Notre Dame

[TCHOF]

Um, they are both terrible

[mendy]

Mar 14, 2024 17:36:48 GMT -5 IrishMike said:

If Jones doesn't work out we are rolling with Lock. If that doesn't work we are in prime position to draft Manning in a few years.

You do realize he is not his uncles? He will be starting his sophomore year and still not starting. Arch Manning is not his uncle's or his Grandfather.

[IrishMike]

Mar 14, 2024 18:33:59 GMT -5 mendy said:

Mar 14, 2024 17:36:48 GMT -5 IrishMike said:

If Jones doesn't work out we are rolling with Lock. If that doesn't work we are in prime position to draft Manning in a few years.

You do realize he is not his uncles? He will be starting his sophomore year and still not starting. Arch Manning is not his uncle's or his Grandfather.

That was said tongue in cheek but we have no idea what he is. He could be better than anyone in his family or a complete bum.

[bluebuddha]

Mar 14, 2024 18:28:39 GMT -5 TCHOF said:

Um, they are both terrible

Yes but one is definitley healthy and doesn't need a insurance policy if he plays. The other one might or might not be healthy and will be owed more money if he can't stay healthy.

The business decision is easy the moral decision might be muddy depending on your faith in Jones' ability. We had no money to get better QB outside of Russel signing here and I am using better in the broadest way here. I really believe the best business play is to get a QB via draft and reset the QB salaries on our roster.

[Rangers13]

Mar 14, 2024 14:06:23 GMT -5 DonnieYen said:

What would be so bad if we can't draft a top QB of drafting Maryland's QB Taulia or Notre Dame's QB?

When he is ready for the draft I say let's get Taulia Tagovailoa! I am a University Of Maryland Fan I watch all there games Taulia is the real deal like his brother Tua on Miami! Taulia Tagovailoa would look great in Giants Blue!

I'm A Maryland fan I see a lot of Taulia Tagovailoa he is the real deal like his brother in Miami. If you don't believe me that Tua is the real deal believe me I Live in Punta Gorda Florida because I listen to Giants on the radio streaming because there never on TV here hardly I watch a lot of Bucs and Dolphins games. Tua ended the season strong winning 7 in a row and almost making the playoffs in his second year in the NFL his first year the Dolphins stunted his growth by choosing to play Fitzpatrick instead. as for Taulia he guided Maryland last year to the Pinstripe Bowl where they crushed West Virginia Taulia had a huge game! Taulia will most likely enter the draft next year I really think The Giants should draft him!

if Gettleman was GM we would have gotten a QB in the first round which is a mistake QB is not our biggest need we should draft a QB next year! I like Taulia from Maryland!

First let me say not only in the draft but also in free agency we had to fortify the lines defensive line and offensive line and I believe we did that! This was the best draft I have seen in a while! A+ I think next year we should get the Maryland QB Taulia Tua's little brother! What do you guys think?First let me say not only in the draft but also in free agency we had to fortify the lines defensive line and offensive line and I believe we did that! This was the best draft I have seen in a while! A+ I think next year we should get the Maryland QB Taulia Tua's little brother! What do you guys think?

Jones I agree with unless we make the Playoffs but Saquon is having a great comeback season. What I would like to see is Jones brought back on a three year deal and draft University Of Maryland QB Taulia Tua's little brother!

you realize with a Washington Loss or Seattle loss we are in the playoffs even if we lose on Christmas Eve to the Vikings! Washington plays San Francisco Seattle plays Detroit. We have a good chance to make the playoffs if The Giants improve the wide receivers in the off-season we should be better next year we are improved a team on the rise! I would draft The University Of Maryland's QB Tua's Little brother Taulia! I'm a Maryland fan I watch him every weekend last two years he guided the Terps to two bowl games last year the Pinstripe Bowl and the Terps won! This year The Dukes Mayonnaise Bowl! Trust me guys he is really good but he could fall to us in the draft because he is short a few inches shorter then his big brother Tua! But I would sign Jones too a small 3 year deal to mentor Taulia!

If I'm the Giants I'm drafting QB of University Of Maryland Tua's little brother Taulia he will probably fall to us because he is a short guy teams think he is to short. I'm a University of Maryland fan trust me when I say Taulia is the real deal! In 2021 he won the Pinstripe Bowl in 2022 he won the Dukes Mayonnaise Bowl! He is NFL Ready and as good if not better as his older brother who plays for Miami! I would sign Daniel Jones to a 3 year deal to Mentor Taulia and to have options Incase this year is a Fluke for Jones!If I'm the Giants I'm drafting QB of University Of Maryland Tua's little brother Taulia he will probably fall to us because he is a short guy teams think he is to short. I'm a University of Maryland fan trust me when I say Taulia is the real deal! In 2021 he won the Pinstripe Bowl in 2022 he won the Dukes Mayonnaise Bowl! He is NFL Ready and as good if not better as his older brother who plays for Miami! I would sign Daniel Jones to a 3 year deal to Mentor Taulia and to have options Incase this year is a Fluke for Jones!

Taulia is gonna fall to later rounds trust me he is really short we get the need players early Taulia in later rounds teams will pass on him but they shouldn't...

I trust the GM and Coach too I won't be to butt hurt if we don't draft Taulia I'm a Maryland fan was born in Staten Island NY but grew up in Maryland had two sisters go to Maryland I just really like the kid probably know more about him then anyone on this forum I've watched all his games he is a special one!

Dolphins QB Tua's little Brother Maryland's QB Taulia we should get this guy after re-signing Jones I Think Jones is veteran enough to mentor the kid!

But we should draft Taulia Tagovailoa as our franchise QB if that means we draft an offensive lineman in the first round first pick then pick Taulia Tagovailoa in the second round then so be it id do it! I'm a Maryland fan I watch all there games and like his brother Tua Taulia is the real deal he has guided Maryland to his third Bowl game this year first one was the Pinstripe Bowl second was the Dukes Mayo Bowl and this Saturday he is in the Music City Bowl won the first two bowl games by a lot! He will drop in the draft his critics say he is to short but guys just look at the dolphins that could be the Giants if we draft Taulia Tagovailoa!But we should draft Taulia Tagovailoa as our franchise QB if that means we draft an offensive lineman in the first round first pick then pick Taulia Tagovailoa in the second round then so be it id do it! I'm a Maryland fan I watch all there games and like his brother Tua Taulia is the real deal he has guided Maryland to his third Bowl game this year first one was the Pinstripe Bowl second was the Dukes Mayo Bowl and this Saturday he is in the Music City Bowl won the first two bowl games by a lot! He will drop in the draft his critics say he is to short but guys just look at the dolphins that could be the Giants if we draft Taulia Tagovailoa!

I like Tua's little brother Taulia I'm a Maryland fan I've watched all his gamees he is the real deal like his big brother! Guided Maryland to three Bowl Games won two of them didn't play yesterday didn't want to get injured before the draft. Also what about Notre Dame's QB isn't he draft eligible he's also really good!

Taulia Tagovailoa and Steve Hartman of Maryland and Notre DameTaulia Tagovailoa and Steve Hartman of Maryland and Notre Dame

What about Sam Hartman out of Notre Dame? I was thinking of University of Maryland QB Taulia Tua's little brother but he is in the transfer bubble looking to play a 5th year of college ball may be for Miami? So what about Sam Hartman?What about Sam Hartman out of Notre Dame? I was thinking of University of Maryland QB Taulia Tua's little brother but he is in the transfer bubble looking to play a 5th year of college ball may be for Miami? So what about Sam Hartman?

I like a healthy obsession

[giantbob71]

Mar 14, 2024 18:55:33 GMT -5 IrishMike said:

Mar 14, 2024 18:33:59 GMT -5 mendy said:

You do realize he is not his uncles? He will be starting his sophomore year and still not starting. Arch Manning is not his uncle's or his Grandfather.

That was said tongue in cheek but we have no idea what he is. He could be better than anyone in his family or a complete bum.

So far, he's a bum. He was 3rd string last year...and when the #2 announced his intention to transfer (before the CFP), Texas boosters got together and gave Ewers a big NIL deal, to stay. Rumors are he's a great kid but unimpressive in practices.

[Fletch842]

personally if we go after a day 3 lower tier QB, I'd prefer Milton or Rattler over either of those 2.

[miggs]

Maybe just maybe, Schoen is trying to sucker teams into thinking he wants a QB with 6th pick in order to get teams who do want a QB to offer him a ton in draft picks so the Giants can move down. But is that smart?

[Fletch842]

Mar 15, 2024 18:41:28 GMT -5 miggs said:

Maybe just maybe, Schoen is trying to sucker teams into thinking he wants a QB with 6th pick in order to get teams who do want a QB to offer him a ton in draft picks so the Giants can move down. But is that smart?

or trade with Chargers, leaving us an additional position player to choose from.

[myronguyton29]

Mar 15, 2024 18:41:28 GMT -5 miggs said:

Maybe just maybe, Schoen is trying to sucker teams into thinking he wants a QB with 6th pick in order to get teams who do want a QB to offer him a ton in draft picks so the Giants can move down. But is that smart?

you might be right and we could use them....

[DonnieYen]

Mar 14, 2024 18:20:30 GMT -5 lt56 said:

explain this obsession with Taulia Tagovailoa who is considered a Day 3 maybe even Undrafted Free Agent who didn't get a Combine Invite? Wish him luck though, maybe he ends up being the next Brock Purdy

as for Sam Hartman...HELL NO! he was a much better QB at Wake Forest but nothing but inconsistency at Notre Dame

I'm a Maryland fan saw all his games I know he is as good as his brother he'd be a day 2 or 3 steal!

[DonnieYen]

We could get another defensive end at 6 or offensive linemen or wide receiver if McCarthy is there at 6 I'm taking him it's not a reach he is really good! I like Lock!

[DonnieYen]

Mar 14, 2024 20:10:35 GMT -5 Rangers13 said:

Mar 14, 2024 14:06:23 GMT -5 DonnieYen said:

What would be so bad if we can't draft a top QB of drafting Maryland's QB Taulia or Notre Dame's QB?

When he is ready for the draft I say let's get Taulia Tagovailoa! I am a University Of Maryland Fan I watch all there games Taulia is the real deal like his brother Tua on Miami! Taulia Tagovailoa would look great in Giants Blue!

I'm A Maryland fan I see a lot of Taulia Tagovailoa he is the real deal like his brother in Miami. If you don't believe me that Tua is the real deal believe me I Live in Punta Gorda Florida because I listen to Giants on the radio streaming because there never on TV here hardly I watch a lot of Bucs and Dolphins games. Tua ended the season strong winning 7 in a row and almost making the playoffs in his second year in the NFL his first year the Dolphins stunted his growth by choosing to play Fitzpatrick instead. as for Taulia he guided Maryland last year to the Pinstripe Bowl where they crushed West Virginia Taulia had a huge game! Taulia will most likely enter the draft next year I really think The Giants should draft him!

if Gettleman was GM we would have gotten a QB in the first round which is a mistake QB is not our biggest need we should draft a QB next year! I like Taulia from Maryland!

First let me say not only in the draft but also in free agency we had to fortify the lines defensive line and offensive line and I believe we did that! This was the best draft I have seen in a while! A+ I think next year we should get the Maryland QB Taulia Tua's little brother! What do you guys think?First let me say not only in the draft but also in free agency we had to fortify the lines defensive line and offensive line and I believe we did that! This was the best draft I have seen in a while! A+ I think next year we should get the Maryland QB Taulia Tua's little brother! What do you guys think?

Jones I agree with unless we make the Playoffs but Saquon is having a great comeback season. What I would like to see is Jones brought back on a three year deal and draft University Of Maryland QB Taulia Tua's little brother!

you realize with a Washington Loss or Seattle loss we are in the playoffs even if we lose on Christmas Eve to the Vikings! Washington plays San Francisco Seattle plays Detroit. We have a good chance to make the playoffs if The Giants improve the wide receivers in the off-season we should be better next year we are improved a team on the rise! I would draft The University Of Maryland's QB Tua's Little brother Taulia! I'm a Maryland fan I watch him every weekend last two years he guided the Terps to two bowl games last year the Pinstripe Bowl and the Terps won! This year The Dukes Mayonnaise Bowl! Trust me guys he is really good but he could fall to us in the draft because he is short a few inches shorter then his big brother Tua! But I would sign Jones too a small 3 year deal to mentor Taulia!

If I'm the Giants I'm drafting QB of University Of Maryland Tua's little brother Taulia he will probably fall to us because he is a short guy teams think he is to short. I'm a University of Maryland fan trust me when I say Taulia is the real deal! In 2021 he won the Pinstripe Bowl in 2022 he won the Dukes Mayonnaise Bowl! He is NFL Ready and as good if not better as his older brother who plays for Miami! I would sign Daniel Jones to a 3 year deal to Mentor Taulia and to have options Incase this year is a Fluke for Jones!If I'm the Giants I'm drafting QB of University Of Maryland Tua's little brother Taulia he will probably fall to us because he is a short guy teams think he is to short. I'm a University of Maryland fan trust me when I say Taulia is the real deal! In 2021 he won the Pinstripe Bowl in 2022 he won the Dukes Mayonnaise Bowl! He is NFL Ready and as good if not better as his older brother who plays for Miami! I would sign Daniel Jones to a 3 year deal to Mentor Taulia and to have options Incase this year is a Fluke for Jones!

Taulia is gonna fall to later rounds trust me he is really short we get the need players early Taulia in later rounds teams will pass on him but they shouldn't...

I trust the GM and Coach too I won't be to butt hurt if we don't draft Taulia I'm a Maryland fan was born in Staten Island NY but grew up in Maryland had two sisters go to Maryland I just really like the kid probably know more about him then anyone on this forum I've watched all his games he is a special one!

Dolphins QB Tua's little Brother Maryland's QB Taulia we should get this guy after re-signing Jones I Think Jones is veteran enough to mentor the kid!

But we should draft Taulia Tagovailoa as our franchise QB if that means we draft an offensive lineman in the first round first pick then pick Taulia Tagovailoa in the second round then so be it id do it! I'm a Maryland fan I watch all there games and like his brother Tua Taulia is the real deal he has guided Maryland to his third Bowl game this year first one was the Pinstripe Bowl second was the Dukes Mayo Bowl and this Saturday he is in the Music City Bowl won the first two bowl games by a lot! He will drop in the draft his critics say he is to short but guys just look at the dolphins that could be the Giants if we draft Taulia Tagovailoa!But we should draft Taulia Tagovailoa as our franchise QB if that means we draft an offensive lineman in the first round first pick then pick Taulia Tagovailoa in the second round then so be it id do it! I'm a Maryland fan I watch all there games and like his brother Tua Taulia is the real deal he has guided Maryland to his third Bowl game this year first one was the Pinstripe Bowl second was the Dukes Mayo Bowl and this Saturday he is in the Music City Bowl won the first two bowl games by a lot! He will drop in the draft his critics say he is to short but guys just look at the dolphins that could be the Giants if we draft Taulia Tagovailoa!

I like Tua's little brother Taulia I'm a Maryland fan I've watched all his gamees he is the real deal like his big brother! Guided Maryland to three Bowl Games won two of them didn't play yesterday didn't want to get injured before the draft. Also what about Notre Dame's QB isn't he draft eligible he's also really good!

Taulia Tagovailoa and Steve Hartman of Maryland and Notre DameTaulia Tagovailoa and Steve Hartman of Maryland and Notre Dame

What about Sam Hartman out of Notre Dame? I was thinking of University of Maryland QB Taulia Tua's little brother but he is in the transfer bubble looking to play a 5th year of college ball may be for Miami? So what about Sam Hartman?What about Sam Hartman out of Notre Dame? I was thinking of University of Maryland QB Taulia Tua's little brother but he is in the transfer bubble looking to play a 5th year of college ball may be for Miami? So what about Sam Hartman?

View Attachment

I like a healthy obsession

Thats fair Im Obsessed I'm passionate I'm a Diehard Maryland fan I watch all there games. Totally fair my friend! I probably know more about Taulia then anyone on here even that his critics pick on his short stature that I think is BS he is as good as his brother Tua! 

[vinnie]

Mar 16, 2024 21:08:22 GMT -5 DonnieYen said:

Mar 14, 2024 18:20:30 GMT -5 lt56 said:

explain this obsession with Taulia Tagovailoa who is considered a Day 3 maybe even Undrafted Free Agent who didn't get a Combine Invite? Wish him luck though, maybe he ends up being the next Brock Purdy

as for Sam Hartman...HELL NO! he was a much better QB at Wake Forest but nothing but inconsistency at Notre Dame

I'm a Maryland fan saw all his games I know he is as good as his brother he'd be a day 2 or 3 steal!

Wait, you went to Maryland?!

[DonnieYen]

Mar 17, 2024 20:42:48 GMT -5 vinnie said:

Mar 16, 2024 21:08:22 GMT -5 DonnieYen said:

I'm a Maryland fan saw all his games I know he is as good as his brother he'd be a day 2 or 3 steal!

Wait, you went to Maryland?!

I lived there yes Olney Maryland and Frederick Maryland I grew up there sadly I'm not smart enough to go to college I'm good at Science and History and I'm really interested in quantum physics and I'm really good at jeopardy but I'm bad at Math and English I have learning disabilities despite being really smart and intellectual. Two of my sisters went there my sister Karen is a genius was studying to be a doctor but got pregnant and dropped out to become a house wife and mother to two beautiful daughters and and awesome son! she is now at 46 going back to school. My sister Tracey graduated from Maryland she is now a teacher! My family is a family of geniuses smart enough to go to Harvard but not enough money. My dad was thinking of going to Fordham University but ended up going to Wagner College graduating with honors! My dad is the smartest man I know!

[vinnie]

Mar 18, 2024 16:34:25 GMT -5 DonnieYen said:

Mar 17, 2024 20:42:48 GMT -5 vinnie said:

Wait, you went to Maryland?!

I lived there yes Olney Maryland and Frederick Maryland I grew up there sadly I'm not smart enough to go to college I'm good at Science and History and I'm really interested in quantum physics and I'm really good at jeopardy but I'm bad at Math and English I have learning disabilities despite being really smart and intellectual. Two of my sisters went there my sister Karen is a genius was studying to be a doctor but got pregnant and dropped out to become a house wife and mother to two beautiful daughters and and awesome son! she is now at 46 going back to school. My sister Tracey graduated from Maryland she is now a teacher! My family is a family of geniuses smart enough to go to Harvard but not enough money. My dad was thinking of going to Fordham University but ended up going to Wagner College graduating with honors! My dad is the smartest man I know!

No scholarship opportunities with all that smartness?