|
Post by Nick6475 on Apr 4, 2024 17:21:08 GMT -5
If the QBs are gone and you have the choice between a WR and Joe Alt what do you do? Let’s keep in mind, Neal or our new swing tackle are not a given. The OL can go from cautiously optimistic to log jam of talent with Alt. (unless he can’t bend which wouldn’t shock me) Or they go WR and welcome in year 13 of cross your fingers on the OL. Alt is a given? A couple years ago the Giants drafted a "given" OL in Evan Neal. The draft is never a "given"
|
|
|
Post by Rangers13 on Apr 4, 2024 17:22:27 GMT -5
If the QBs are gone and you have the choice between a WR and Joe Alt what do you do? Let’s keep in mind, Neal or our new swing tackle are not a given. The OL can go from cautiously optimistic to log jam of talent with Alt. (unless he can’t bend which wouldn’t shock me) Or they go WR and welcome in year 13 of cross your fingers on the OL. Alt is a given? A couple years ago the Giants drafted a "given" OL in Evan Neal. The draft is never a "given" I think I spelled that out
|
|
|
Post by Roosevelt on Apr 4, 2024 18:12:35 GMT -5
Coaches are involved in personnel moves as much as the GM. The coaches tell the GM who and what positions they need, the GM tries their best to get the players or the equivalent. TC's failure's were just as equal on the field as they were off. his defenses were so pathetic with a 1score lead he was going for on 4th down because they gave up so many final drive leads i think he and reese were never on the same page. I don't think Tom valued complimentary football. As an example, I thought the Gilbride called about as risky and stupid an offense as it gets.
And while I always hated Buddy Ryan, I fully understand why he took a shot at him.
|
|
|
Post by BigBlueDog42 on Apr 4, 2024 18:20:36 GMT -5
his defenses were so pathetic with a 1score lead he was going for on 4th down because they gave up so many final drive leads i think he and reese were never on the same page. I don't think Tom valued complimentary football. As an example, I thought the Gilbride called about as risky and stupid an offense as it gets.
And while I always hated Buddy Ryan, I fully understand why he took a shot at him. Your money there Gillbride was high risk high reward in a nut shell often wonder what Eli would have done running a good offense that was lets say more conventional. A lot of his picks where he was throwing where the WR wasn't were because ether WR wasn't where ehe should have been it was complicated they had to see the defense the same as Eli saw it.
|
|
mendy
Starter
Posts: 3,941
|
Post by mendy on Apr 4, 2024 18:21:13 GMT -5
Here's an ugly reminder of our starting Oline by game for 2023.
AT- Andrew Thomas BB- Ben Bredeson JMS- John Michael Schmitz Jr. MG- Mark Glowinski EN- Evan Neal
JE- Joshua Ezeudu MM- Marcus McKethan SL- Shane Lemieux JP- Justin Pugh TP- Tyre Phillips
MP- Matt Peart
Opp
| LT | LG
| C
| RG
| RT
| DAL | AT
| BB
| JMS
| MG
| EN
| ARI | JE | BB
| JMS
| MM
| EN
| SF | JE | SL
| JMS
| MM
| EN
| SEA | JE | BB
| JMS
| MM
| EN
| MIA | JE | MG
| BB
| MM
| EN
| BUF | JE | JP
| BB
| MG
| EN
| WAS | JP | MM
| BB
| MG
| TP
| NYJ | JP | BB
| JMS
| MG
| TP
| LV
| AT | JP
| JMS
| BB
| EN
| DAL | AT | JP
| JMS
| BB
| TP
| WAS | AT
| JP
| JMS
| BB
| TP
| NE | AT | JP
| JMS
| BB
| TP
| GB | AT | JP
| JMS
| BB
| TP
| NO
| AT | JP
| JMS
| BB
| TP
| PHI | AT | JP
| JMS
| BB
| TP
| LAR | AT | JP
| JMS
| BB
| TP
| PHI | AT | JP
| BB
| MG
| MP
|
Interesting that the meat of the schedule was the first six games and that's when Jones got pummeled the most. We need to remember he was missing other positions as well, TE, RB, Slot.
|
|
|
Post by jimmieray on Apr 4, 2024 18:36:27 GMT -5
Anyone know the status on Tyree Phillips? I know he had surgery, but also might be a FA. Wouldn't he be a decent depth consideration?
|
|
|
Post by Roosevelt on Apr 4, 2024 21:20:41 GMT -5
Anyone know the status on Tyree Phillips? I know he had surgery, but also might be a FA. Wouldn't he be a decent depth consideration? Yes FA.
|
|
|
Post by GameTime on Apr 5, 2024 6:49:31 GMT -5
Anyone know the status on Tyree Phillips? I know he had surgery, but also might be a FA. Wouldn't he be a decent depth consideration? even as a depth player he gets hurt. I wouldn't go back to that well unless absolutely necessary, ankle ACL Quad
|
|