Draft re-do

[Turbo]

There are a lot of these draft type re-do deals out there. Here is what I wonder.

Suppose we know NOW how each player has worked out, injuries, suspensions...everything with perfect knowledge. All teams know it. If we go back three drafts, who would we likely have drafted each time, understanding that each team would do the same.

No trades allowed.

[giantlegacy]

This is impossible to do without the context of what other teams ahead of us would have done also.
Because we could make an all star roster every year if we eliminated the other 31 teams from being part of this

[TEM]

Draft re-dos make idiots feel smart. The only purpose of them.

There is no guarantee :

Brady wins 6 with another team

LT is the best defender in history on the Saints . (Saints had the #1 pick in 81)

Rae Carrut goes to prison for attempted murder if he is not in Carolina ( perhaps someone gives him a voice of reason)

Jarome Brown and Derrick Thomas Die is car accidents if drafted differently.

We have knowledge of the time line that unfolded. Not of any other.

The Giants' have 4 in the case. Would we if history was written differently ?