Who Stays, Who goes? You Decide….

[myronguyton29]

Nov 28, 2022 7:33:31 GMT -5 @karmicjuggernaught said:

Nov 27, 2022 19:53:47 GMT -5 myronguyton29 said:

yeah he is though now I don't see him making much noise numbers wise but maybe affecting in other ways. And still I personally believe Lawrence was wreaking major major having and his name was getting called often when Leo was out...........

He was crushing it without Williams in there..

absolutely was and I don't understand how Leo being back would change that.................

[yoho]

I think Ezudu could develop into a good guard. Gates has to be a starter at guard or center. Glowinski should not be a starter, but he’s on a three year contract. I’d keep Phillips as a swing tackle. We need inside Backers. Beavers who was hurt in preseason was looking great, but we need another. Keep Jackson and Moreau and get another corner. Hoping Flott supplants Holmes, as he just gets picked on regularly. Red another DT. And Jesus Christ Almighty please find a punter that can kick to the coffin corner. Get rid of the Scottish hammer and find the Scottish nine iron.

[giantsalmon]

Nov 28, 2022 15:21:50 GMT -5 yoho said:

I think Ezudu could develop into a good guard. Gates has to be a starter at guard or center. Glowinski should not be a starter, but he’s on a three year contract. I’d keep Phillips as a swing tackle. We need inside Backers. Beavers who was hurt in preseason was looking great, but we need another. Keep Jackson and Moreau and get another corner. Hoping Flott supplants Holmes, as he just gets picked on regularly. Red another DT. And Jesus Christ Almighty please find a punter that can kick to the coffin corner. Get rid of the Scottish hammer and find the Scottish nine iron.

You may be right about the scottish hammer, but his coverage teams have let him down repeatedly the last couple weeks. There were mis plays inside the 5 downing the football that need to be made.

[miggs]

The Giants next season have various starter positions on both sides of the ball they need improvement. Giants will have more depth.

But will the Giants re-sign both Jones and Barkley, and if so, will Giants be a far better team with the new additions? And if not, will the Giants new QB and running back be an upgrade or will the Giants be in a re-build?

I'm interested in seeing what Daboll does with next year's roster. Overall, can Giants average more points per game? Can Daboll produce more ppg than Judge did?

Giants stayed fairly steady from game one to date with no real improvement no matter whether Giants played better or lesser opponents.

Will Giants throw more passes and run less?

Will Kafka be the play caller? Let's see how he performs the rest of the season.

if Daboll employs more two-back formations will such improve both the Giants running and passing game.

With Wink return as DC? Hope so.

Will Giants opponents score fewer points?

Will Adoree Jackson who can't cover deep be the Giants no. 1 corner? Will Holmes start. Hope not.

One thing I'm confident in is that a healthy Beavers will help solidify the ILB position.

[Morehead State]

Nov 29, 2022 9:26:16 GMT -5 miggs said:

The Giants next season have various positions on both sides of the ball they need to improve. Giants should improve and have more depth.

But will the Giants re-sign both Jones and Barkley, and if so, will Giants be a far better team with the new additions? And if not, will the Giants new QB and running back be an upgrade or will the Giants be in a re-build?

I'm interested in seeing what Daboll does with next year's roster. Overall, can Giants average more points per game? Can Daboll produce more ppg than Judge did?

Giants stayed fairly steady from game one to date with no real improvement no matter whether Giants played better or lesser opponents.

Will Giants throw more passes and run less?

Will Kafka be the play caller? Let's see how he performs the rest of the season.

Will Daboll use more two-back formations to improve both the Giants running and passing game.

With Wink return as DC? Hope so.

Will Giants opponents score fewer points?

Will Adoree Jackson who can't cover deep be the Giants no. 1 corner? Will Holmes start. Hope not.

One thing I'm confident in is that a healthy Beavers will help solidify the ILB position.

I'm guessing (and that's all it is) that the FO doesn't value Saquan as a long term solution as much as some folks think.

He'll be entering his 6th season.  That's pushing the length of a RB's peak effectiveness in the NFL.

I do think there is a chance they move on.  Having said that, a one year deal or a franchise tag for Saquan might be possible.  I think it would be a mistake to make a longer term commitment to him.

[miggs]

Want to see how Barkley performs the rest of the season. Has to show he can consistently catch the ball. .

The Giants need another RB that is both powerful and quick. Might be Brightwell.

[Roswell]

Nov 27, 2022 15:21:00 GMT -5 Kase1 said:

Nov 27, 2022 14:29:47 GMT -5 BigBlueDog42 said:

No one is crushing Lawrence we are getting killed off tackle between the DE and the OLB  5 to 7 holes are

killing this defense it cropped up in the Jags game and teams have been going after it since.

when you watch the ILBs on tape their is hesitation a lot they are good guard to guard most of the time getting out to tackle inside or out not so much.

A stud LB that can play sideline to sideline and cover would be HUUUUUUUGE. We have like nobody at ILB

I DID like Beavers at ILB til he got injured

I agree.

When you consider how good the DTs are, the ILBs have really let this team down.  Beevers looked great to me.  But they need a guy like Roquan Smith.  A leader, right in the middle, that makes big plays.  Other than that, another rangy CB would be great.

on O, WRs, WRs, WRs.   And a great G or 2.

Plus a punter and a punt returner.