|
Post by Danke Schoen on Apr 26, 2024 7:54:46 GMT -5
Ok, that’s great, I used to have somewhat of the same mindset but not in this draft and where we were drafting. So how long do you think this team will take to build up until we can get our “plug and play” QB? When do you think we should draft our next QB? Do you agree it will take at least 1-2 years for most QB’s to turn into a playoff caliber QB, even with a very good supporting team? Do you think drafting ANY QB is a risk for a bust or just being average at best? I honestly don’t know what to make of your mindset given your posting history about Maye, Penix, Willams and the rest of the “top QBs.” After reading a few posts I think it just reiterates my belief that you’re operating on pure emotion, hindsight and hypocrisy. Obviously below is very interesting given the complete 180 you had between December/January and now. But really interesting to me is that on November 9th you admit you’ve never watched Maye at all but on November 19th you say you’ve been watching him for the last 4-6 weeks. That questionable history aside… So I guess it was what? You getting caught up in everyone else’s opinion of Maye during the draft lead up that made you change your mind from “Maye is Jones 2.0. Hard pass. Forcing that pick would be Jones all over again. Schoen would be a ****ing idiot to trade picks to move up and draft Maye” to “I would have given up two 1sts and a 2nd to move up and draft Maye.” Still haven’t watched Maye play at all, really like Penix skills but injury history makes him a hard pass for me. The 3 main ones I started watching 4-6 weeks ago were Penix, Maye and Williams. I like Penix the most out of the 3 but his injury history pretty much negates everything. I still need to watch Nix and Daniels but I absolutely do not like Maye and unfortunately I recently read last night was the 6th time the Giants scouts (and I believe Schoen) have watched him in person this year. I don’t know how they could think he’s a franchise QB. It would be Jones all over again IMO. *If they plan on drafting Maye, I’d rather trade back, roll with Tyrod or some other FA next year until Jones gets back and look for another QB in 2025. That is last ditch resort to me because I think if you have a top pick and don’t have to give up any draft capital to move up for a QB you want then get him. On the other hand, I wouldn’t want to force drafting a guy like Maye just because we’re in a position to do so and go through the same shit we did with DJ for 3-4 years. I think a lot of people will be whining if Schoen gives up draft picks to move up a spot or two for Maye but surely he’s not that stupid, right? As in stoopid enough to draft Maye, let alone give up draft pick? I wouldn’t like it if he drafted Maye with the 1st or 2nd pick but imagine if Schoen is that convinced that he’s “the guy” and mortgages our future picks, along with his job, to move up and get him? I don’t think he could be that stoopid but, if he was, I would love to hear how many fans now thought beating washington, NO, NE, GB….was worth the future picks we gave up. I’m definitely no QB guru and I’ll get into further detail later in the year after watching more, but again Penix looked the best to me but his injuries pretty much take him off the table IMO and I don’t get the Maye hype, he didn’t look good at all to me, pretty average to below average actually. I wouldn’t touch Maye as of now. Again, who ever said we will or need to start a rookie QB? As far as a QB fixing the problem…no one ever said that either but we clearly need a new QB and if we’re in a position to draft one without having to give up the farm then you can’t pass on that. Having said all of that, I’m not impressed with any of these top prospect QB’s so far, especially Maye. I’ve said it before, I’ll say it again. I’m not pro QB scout but I don’t get all the hype behind Maye. I’ve watched a few of his recent games and have watched the entire Clemson game so far (along with the USC/UCLA game) and while I’ve seen Maye make on really nice TD pass, I’ve seen him miss a lot more. I feel like I’m watching a reincarnation of DJ. Pocket awareness sucks, relies on his legs too much, too inconsistent, etc. He’s currently 9/20 for 142 yards and literally half of those yards came off 2 plays. I’ll still give him some time but right now, if we drafted him, I’d be about as po’d as when we drafted DJ. Doesn’t mean I wouldn’t support him but I’d be far from ecstatic. I’m also not sold on Williams and not sure he would be a good fit for the Giants but he’s smoking Maye today. *And I do believe Schoen is there today and has already been to quite a few of his games this season, not a good sign IMO. Hope he doesn’t “fall in full bloom love”. think Maye just dropped to 3rd round 16/36 with 209 yards? 44.4 completion %. Ouch. Didn’t play one currently ranked team all year? Beats up on scrubs, sounds very familiar. Well you didn’t like Jones so I assume we’ll listen to you bitch about Jones 2.0 (aka Maye) until Schoen and Dabs get fired in a couple years and the new GM drafts another QB because I don’t see Maye as a franchise QB but I’ve been wrong before. [Now if Schoen drafts Maye with ANY pick, I’ll be as po’d as when DG drafted DJ but I’ll still support Maye for the first 2 years or so, at least I’ll try, haha. See, I actually watched quite a few of Maye’s games and only a couple of Daniels. I don’t know what to think of Daniels but I’m not a Maye fan in the slightest bit. Having said that, I liked Rosen and there’s been plenty of other QB’s I thought would do well in the NFL that didn’t do well and vice versa. So basically I don’t know shit, just like most of the GM’s who drafted QB’s on that Heisman list, lol.
|
|
|
Post by Bigjeep on Apr 26, 2024 7:55:21 GMT -5
I'm disappointed! What good is a WR without the franchise QB we need? And next year for QB's is slim! Sadly, another crap year is ahead for us!
|
|
|
Post by Bigjeep on Apr 26, 2024 8:00:03 GMT -5
Now they role with Daniel Jones. The dude they made their bed with. In a way, im so tired of the narrative about how this was all a weapons problem. Well, let's see what Jones does, im sure we will still invest in OL, RB, and TE in this draft. We will be loaded Playoffs are the expectation. Curious to see these new age roster development concepts work, in reality. Lets put a great team around Daniel Jones and watch, and see. Been doing that for years and I'm sick of it! Jones is not the guy and won't last the season!
|
|
|
Post by Fletch842 on Apr 26, 2024 8:01:31 GMT -5
I wonder if Trey Benson will be our pick second rd. Young rb to pair with a young wr. I wouldn't mind Ruke Orhorhoro either. I think they go cb good value still there. Like Benson a lot, but we have other larger holes. I would rather go OL to be honest. I think we need to help out the secondary though with 47. Maybe trade up. I think there will be some very good RBs in the third, and we will be going defense in the 2nd, most likely secondary. It's a greater need, and better draft value.
|
|
Merlin
Special Teams
Posts: 358
|
Post by Merlin on Apr 26, 2024 8:12:36 GMT -5
Please, please, please stay on offense!!
Double up at WR(Kevin Coleman or Polk) since Mitchell should be gone. Cool with OT Fischer or TE Sanders if not.
Go RB in the 3rd.
|
|
|
Post by scoostraw on Apr 26, 2024 8:13:07 GMT -5
It's frustrating to watch teams like Pittsburgh and Atlanta dramatically upgrade their QB position, while we seem to be unable to do so.
|
|
|
Post by idkaname on Apr 26, 2024 8:17:37 GMT -5
It's frustrating to watch teams like Pittsburgh and Atlanta dramatically upgrade their QB position, while we seem to be unable to do so. "dramatic upgrade" is drafting a guy that has never taken a snap in the NFL or picking up an aging QB that hasn't been to the playoffs in years? You guys sure do hype up every move made by other teams and downplay the Giants hard. pretty cute
|
|
|
Post by scoostraw on Apr 26, 2024 8:23:20 GMT -5
"dramatic upgrade" is drafting a guy that has never taken a snap in the NFL You mean like Kenny Pickett?
|
|
|
Post by SG88 on Apr 26, 2024 8:35:02 GMT -5
I'm very stoked about another 6-11 season. LFG 😄 If the Giants selected JJ McCarthy, Penix or Nix you would have believed we’d have a record better than 6-11 next season? Not at all. The Giants were simply in a bad spot at the draft. Those end of the season wins were totally useless. I do feel like they tried very hard to trade up to 3. It just didn't work since all 3 of those teams needed a QB. I don't mind the Nabers pick. They just better hope that none of the 3 QBs mentioned end up being really good. We will never shut up about it and the Giants will never hear the end of it.
|
|
|
Post by idkaname on Apr 26, 2024 8:36:30 GMT -5
"dramatic upgrade" is drafting a guy that has never taken a snap in the NFL You mean like Kenny Pickett? no Penix
|
|
|
Post by SG88 on Apr 26, 2024 8:37:46 GMT -5
It's frustrating to watch teams like Pittsburgh and Atlanta dramatically upgrade their QB position, while we seem to be unable to do so. "dramatic upgrade" is drafting a guy that has never taken a snap in the NFL or picking up an aging QB that hasn't been to the playoffs in years? You guys sure do hype up every move made by other teams and downplay the Giants hard. pretty cute In contrast, you have fans that downplay other team's players to boost up our own. I'm not saying it's you, but I've definitely seen it happen on here.
|
|
|
Post by Danke Schoen on Apr 26, 2024 8:41:08 GMT -5
If the Giants selected JJ McCarthy, Penix or Nix you would have believed we’d have a record better than 6-11 next season? Not at all. The Giants were simply in a bad spot at the draft. Those end of the season wins were totally useless. I do feel like they tried very hard to trade up to 3. It just didn't work since all 3 of those teams needed a QB. I don't mind the Nabers pick. They just better hope that none of the 3 QBs mentioned end up being really good. We will never shut up about it and the Giants will never hear the end of it. I guess I couldn’t care less about what other teams are doing. I want the Giants to build a franchise/contender. And by my personal estimation Schoen is doing just that. I don’t get caught up in the fans’ knee jerk instant gratification/emotional rants. But fear not. Just like every year, next year around January/February fans will be calling the 2025 QB class “deep.”
|
|
|
Post by idkaname on Apr 26, 2024 8:45:22 GMT -5
"dramatic upgrade" is drafting a guy that has never taken a snap in the NFL or picking up an aging QB that hasn't been to the playoffs in years? You guys sure do hype up every move made by other teams and downplay the Giants hard. pretty cute In contrast, you have fans that downplay other team's players to boost up our own. I'm not saying it's you, but I've definitely seen it happen on here. I mean it's all opinion and favor at the end of the day. If someone wants to become an NFL GM to "prove" others wrong, they're free to do so. It's just funny when people are applauding transactions before the results back it up. For all I know us drafting Nabors over McCarthy/Penix/or some QB that goes in round 6 could've been a mistake, only time will tell. I'm just surprised the post-draft analysis of us taking a WR wasn't "Giants needed a QB here but got a pretty good WR, Grade B-" LOL
|
|
|
Post by Rangers13 on Apr 26, 2024 8:46:37 GMT -5
It's frustrating to watch teams like Pittsburgh and Atlanta dramatically upgrade their QB position, while we seem to be unable to do so. "dramatic upgrade" is drafting a guy that has never taken a snap in the NFL or picking up an aging QB that hasn't been to the playoffs in years? You guys sure do hype up every move made by other teams and downplay the Giants hard. pretty cute Atlanta signed Cousins and drafted his replacement is what he is saying while Pittsburgh added Wilson and took a flier on Fields. Meanwhile, the Giants have Jones who at the moment is walking a straight line and might not be ready for Sept. We’re trying to help you yet there is only so much we can do.
|
|
|
Post by scoostraw on Apr 26, 2024 8:47:19 GMT -5
Not at all. The Giants were simply in a bad spot at the draft. Those end of the season wins were totally useless. I do feel like they tried very hard to trade up to 3. It just didn't work since all 3 of those teams needed a QB. I don't mind the Nabers pick. They just better hope that none of the 3 QBs mentioned end up being really good. We will never shut up about it and the Giants will never hear the end of it. I guess I couldn’t care less about what other teams are doing. I want the Giants to build a franchise/contender. And by my personal estimation Schoen is doing just that. I don’t get caught up in the fans’ knee jerk instant gratification/emotional rants. But fear not. Just like every year, next year around January/February fans will be calling the 2025 QB class “deep.” I agree. Schoen is a bright guy and I think he has the Giants on the right track. It's the fan in me that gets frustrated and impatient.
|
|
|
Post by Analyst on Apr 26, 2024 9:32:08 GMT -5
The Top 10 overall players still on the board entering Day 2 of the NFL Draft according to The33rdTeam:
1. Kool-Aid McKinstry (CB, Alabama) 2. Jer’Zhan Newton (IDL, Illinois) 3. Ennis Rakestraw Jr. (CB, Mizzou) 4. Keon Coleman (WR, FSU) 5. Ja’Tavion Sanders (TE, Texas) 6. Tyler Nubin (S, Minnesota) 7. Jackson Powers-Johnson (C, Oregon) 8. T’Vondre Sweat (NT, Texas) 9. Kamren Kinchens (S, Miami) 10. Cooper DeJean (CB, Iowa)
|
|
|
Post by repeatchamps on Apr 26, 2024 9:40:30 GMT -5
Please, please, please stay on offense!! Double up at WR(Kevin Coleman or Polk) since Mitchell should be gone. Cool with OT Fischer or TE Sanders if not. Go RB in the 3rd. They probably need to go DB (McKinney gone and Adoree likely gone though he is still out there) or DT with the 2nd round pick, maybe O-line but I think that's for 3rd round and later, perhaps G/T/C hybrid guy from round 3 on. Can use another run stuffing tackle machine ILB'er too.
|
|
|
Post by repeatchamps on Apr 26, 2024 9:47:26 GMT -5
The Top 10 overall players still on the board entering Day 2 of the NFL Draft according to The33rdTeam: 1. Kool-Aid McKinstry (CB, Alabama) 2. Jer’Zhan Newton (IDL, Illinois) 3. Ennis Rakestraw Jr. (CB, Mizzou) 4. Keon Coleman (WR, FSU) 5. Ja’Tavion Sanders (TE, Texas) 6. Tyler Nubin (S, Minnesota) 7. Jackson Powers-Johnson (C, Oregon) 8. T’Vondre Sweat (NT, Texas) 9. Kamren Kinchens (S, Miami) 10. Cooper DeJean (CB, Iowa) I doubt #1 makes it to us. If any of the other 9 can get to us, I'd be good with any of them though the TE and WR fall back behind in priorities right now for my preference. Would be thrilled with 2, 3, 6, 8, 9, 10. 7 is an ok option if he can also play Guard.
|
|
|
Post by vinnie on Apr 26, 2024 9:53:45 GMT -5
So you think we’ll be in a better position to draft someone as equally talented as Penix or Nix next year? I obviously know they can all be busts, Nix, Penix, Daniels, Maye and all the guys that get hyped up next year but at some point you have to roll the dice. way to early to tell who will be available in the draft next year, and we still could take one of the lower tier QBs later in this draft, which could work out, even if the % is much lower. It’s way too early but I think it’s safe to say there won’t be near as many alleged high quality prospects and we’ll be picking quite a bit lower meaning we’ll have to give up more. Sure, we could find the next Romo, Wilson, Dak or even Brady but the odds are highly stacked against that happening and wince our picks are allegedly so valuable, it would be waste to try those odds.
|
|
|
Post by vinnie on Apr 26, 2024 10:05:57 GMT -5
Ok, that’s great, I used to have somewhat of the same mindset but not in this draft and where we were drafting. So how long do you think this team will take to build up until we can get our “plug and play” QB? When do you think we should draft our next QB? Do you agree it will take at least 1-2 years for most QB’s to turn into a playoff caliber QB, even with a very good supporting team? Do you think drafting ANY QB is a risk for a bust or just being average at best? I honestly don’t know what to make of your mindset given your posting history about Maye, Penix, Willams and the rest of the “top QBs.” After reading a few posts I think it just reiterates my belief that you’re operating on pure emotion, hindsight and hypocrisy. Obviously below is very interesting given the complete 180 you had between December/January and now. But really interesting to me is that on November 9th you admit you’ve never watched Maye at all but on November 19th you say you’ve been watching him for the last 4-6 weeks. That questionable history aside… So I guess it was what? You getting caught up in everyone else’s opinion of Maye during the draft lead up that made you change your mind from “Maye is Jones 2.0. Hard pass. Forcing that pick would be Jones all over again. Schoen would be a ****ing idiot to trade picks to move up and draft Maye” to “I would have given up two 1sts and a 2nd to move up and draft Maye.” Still haven’t watched Maye play at all, really like Penix skills but injury history makes him a hard pass for me. The 3 main ones I started watching 4-6 weeks ago were Penix, Maye and Williams. I like Penix the most out of the 3 but his injury history pretty much negates everything. I still need to watch Nix and Daniels but I absolutely do not like Maye and unfortunately I recently read last night was the 6th time the Giants scouts (and I believe Schoen) have watched him in person this year. I don’t know how they could think he’s a franchise QB. It would be Jones all over again IMO. *If they plan on drafting Maye, I’d rather trade back, roll with Tyrod or some other FA next year until Jones gets back and look for another QB in 2025. That is last ditch resort to me because I think if you have a top pick and don’t have to give up any draft capital to move up for a QB you want then get him. On the other hand, I wouldn’t want to force drafting a guy like Maye just because we’re in a position to do so and go through the same shit we did with DJ for 3-4 years. I think a lot of people will be whining if Schoen gives up draft picks to move up a spot or two for Maye but surely he’s not that stupid, right? As in stoopid enough to draft Maye, let alone give up draft pick? I wouldn’t like it if he drafted Maye with the 1st or 2nd pick but imagine if Schoen is that convinced that he’s “the guy” and mortgages our future picks, along with his job, to move up and get him? I don’t think he could be that stoopid but, if he was, I would love to hear how many fans now thought beating washington, NO, NE, GB….was worth the future picks we gave up. I’m definitely no QB guru and I’ll get into further detail later in the year after watching more, but again Penix looked the best to me but his injuries pretty much take him off the table IMO and I don’t get the Maye hype, he didn’t look good at all to me, pretty average to below average actually. I wouldn’t touch Maye as of now. Again, who ever said we will or need to start a rookie QB? As far as a QB fixing the problem…no one ever said that either but we clearly need a new QB and if we’re in a position to draft one without having to give up the farm then you can’t pass on that. Having said all of that, I’m not impressed with any of these top prospect QB’s so far, especially Maye. I’ve said it before, I’ll say it again. I’m not pro QB scout but I don’t get all the hype behind Maye. I’ve watched a few of his recent games and have watched the entire Clemson game so far (along with the USC/UCLA game) and while I’ve seen Maye make on really nice TD pass, I’ve seen him miss a lot more. I feel like I’m watching a reincarnation of DJ. Pocket awareness sucks, relies on his legs too much, too inconsistent, etc. He’s currently 9/20 for 142 yards and literally half of those yards came off 2 plays. I’ll still give him some time but right now, if we drafted him, I’d be about as po’d as when we drafted DJ. Doesn’t mean I wouldn’t support him but I’d be far from ecstatic. I’m also not sold on Williams and not sure he would be a good fit for the Giants but he’s smoking Maye today. *And I do believe Schoen is there today and has already been to quite a few of his games this season, not a good sign IMO. Hope he doesn’t “fall in full bloom love”. 16/36 with 209 yards? 44.4 completion %. Ouch. Didn’t play one currently ranked team all year? Beats up on scrubs, sounds very familiar. Well you didn’t like Jones so I assume we’ll listen to you bitch about Jones 2.0 (aka Maye) until Schoen and Dabs get fired in a couple years and the new GM drafts another QB because I don’t see Maye as a franchise QB but I’ve been wrong before. [Now if Schoen drafts Maye with ANY pick, I’ll be as po’d as when DG drafted DJ but I’ll still support Maye for the first 2 years or so, at least I’ll try, haha. See, I actually watched quite a few of Maye’s games and only a couple of Daniels. I don’t know what to think of Daniels but I’m not a Maye fan in the slightest bit. Having said that, I liked Rosen and there’s been plenty of other QB’s I thought would do well in the NFL that didn’t do well and vice versa. So basically I don’t know shit, just like most of the GM’s who drafted QB’s on that Heisman list, lol. Fantastic! You could have just quoted one or two of my statements since they’re all similar or simply asked me why I think they should have chosen Maye or another QB, but you being you had to post 15-20 quotes of me saying the same thing that I’ve never hid behind. So to answer your question, unlike you did mine, I’m not the GM but as I said if they drafted Maye he wouldn’t have been my favorite choice but I would hope they saw something in him that I didn’t. And AS I SAID, if they couldn’t find a QB out of the 4 remaining, then I don’t think they’re going to have a much better option next year and if they do they’ll have to give up a hell of a lot more then they did this year. See how easy that would have been? You also could have posted my last quote, that about sums it up. Now can you answer my questions please?
|
|
|
Post by PennState1 on Apr 26, 2024 10:07:02 GMT -5
What are we doing at TE?
|
|
|
Post by vinnie on Apr 26, 2024 10:14:40 GMT -5
Not at all. The Giants were simply in a bad spot at the draft. Those end of the season wins were totally useless. I do feel like they tried very hard to trade up to 3. It just didn't work since all 3 of those teams needed a QB. I don't mind the Nabers pick. They just better hope that none of the 3 QBs mentioned end up being really good. We will never shut up about it and the Giants will never hear the end of it. I guess I couldn’t care less about what other teams are doing. I want the Giants to build a franchise/contender. And by my personal estimation Schoen is doing just that. I don’t get caught up in the fans’ knee jerk instant gratification/emotional rants. But fear not. Just like every year, next year around January/February fans will be calling the 2025 QB class “deep.” You sure about that? I don’t recall them saying that in 2022 when Kenny Pickett was the only QB taken in round 1. Or take 2021 when 5 players went in top 15 and only Lawrence is a current starter. I’m sure Schoen would have seen right through the hype of the other 4 QB’s and we wouldn’t have wasted picks moving up, we would just keep Jones another year and maybe draft a QB in 2026 so he could be ready by 2027.
|
|
|
Post by vinnie on Apr 26, 2024 10:23:51 GMT -5
It's frustrating to watch teams like Pittsburgh and Atlanta dramatically upgrade their QB position, while we seem to be unable to do so. "dramatic upgrade" is drafting a guy that has never taken a snap in the NFL or picking up an aging QB that hasn't been to the playoffs in years? You guys sure do hype up every move made by other teams and downplay the Giants hard. pretty cute We have a decade of results and incompetent GM’s to back up that downplay. Then we have fans who cheer every move made by any GM, including Gettleman, pretty cute. It seems like yesterday that our O line was “fixed once and for all” and when Neal was drafted fans were saying how great it was to finally have two bookends at the tackle position for years to come before they even stepped on the field. ****, we don’t even know if JMS will work out. Waller was finally going to open up our offense and DJ was finally going to have a decent O line and weapons to show how good he really could be.
|
|
|
Post by Bigjeep on Apr 26, 2024 11:15:01 GMT -5
"dramatic upgrade" is drafting a guy that has never taken a snap in the NFL or picking up an aging QB that hasn't been to the playoffs in years? You guys sure do hype up every move made by other teams and downplay the Giants hard. pretty cute We have a decade of results and incompetent GM’s to back up that downplay. Then we have fans who cheer every move made by any GM, including Gettleman, pretty cute. It seems like yesterday that our O line was “fixed once and for all” and when Neal was drafted fans were saying how great it was to finally have two bookends at the tackle position for years to come before they even stepped on the field. ****, we don’t even know if JMS will work out. Waller was finally going to open up our offense and DJ was finally going to have a decent O line and weapons to show how good he really could be. SAD!
|
|
|
Post by Analyst on Apr 26, 2024 11:42:46 GMT -5
I just hope Nabers isn't another OBJ. By that, I mean a great WR on a 3-4-5 win team until he gets completely frustrated looking around at where Daniel Jones footballs are going.
QB is the most important position in the NFL however, you can't simply reach for one because you need one. That's how we got DJ IMO.
Scheon has to make this work or he is out.
|
|
|
Post by vinnie on Apr 26, 2024 12:23:00 GMT -5
I just hope Nabers isn't another OBJ. By that, I mean a great WR on a 3-4-5 win team until he gets completely frustrated looking around at where Daniel Jones footballs are going. QB is the most important position in the NFL however, you can't simply reach for one because you need one. That's how we got DJ IMO. Scheon has to make this work or he is out. There’s no doubt Nabors will be a fantastic addition and I think he’ll get us a few more wins, which is great, but that only pushes us further back in the draft when we’re looking for a QB. We could be the next Commanders. There’s lots of years where they had a good O line, very good D line, very good WR’s but they’ve been in QB hell since Cousins left and they haven’t done shit. Better hope like hell Jones gets better, and not just a little better, or as good as his “miraculous” 2022 season. He needs to be much, much, much better than he’s ever been otherwise we’ll always be a fringe or one win playoff team at best. See Dallas Cowboys with Dak, but there are a lot of fans here who seem like they would be happy if we were just relevant going into December.
|
|
|
Post by Fletch842 on Apr 26, 2024 12:25:54 GMT -5
way to early to tell who will be available in the draft next year, and we still could take one of the lower tier QBs later in this draft, which could work out, even if the % is much lower. It’s way too early but I think it’s safe to say there won’t be near as many alleged high quality prospects and we’ll be picking quite a bit lower meaning we’ll have to give up more. Sure, we could find the next Romo, Wilson, Dak or even Brady but the odds are highly stacked against that happening and wince our picks are allegedly so valuable, it would be waste to try those odds. as you get to the lower rounds, the picks become less valuable, and mitigate the risk by default. Rounds 1/2 you should get a starter, and round 3 should produce a major contributor. After that, it drops precipitously.
|
|
|
Post by inconvenientruth on Apr 26, 2024 13:18:32 GMT -5
Guys to look out for at #47 (if Dejan and Mckinstry go early):
OG Cooper Beebe CB Melton SS Tyler Nubin
|
|
nyg2
Starter
Posts: 4,562
|
Post by nyg2 on Apr 26, 2024 14:32:19 GMT -5
Just to add a few more names that the Giants could be potentially looking at today:
DB: Cooper DeJean 6'0, 205lbs Jaden Hicks 6'2, 211lbs T.J. Tampa 6'1, 189lbs Cam Hart 6'3, 202lbs Tyler Nubin 6'1, 199lbs
Dline: T'Vondre Sweat 6'4 366lbs Braden Friske 6'4 292lbs Kris Jenkins 6'3 299lbs Ruke Orhorhoro 6'4 294lbs
RB: Trey Benson 6'0, 216lbs Jonathon Brooks 6'0 216lbs
Oline: Dominick Puni 6'5, 313lbs Sedrick Van Pran-Granger 6'4, 298lbs Zak Zinter 6'6, 303lbs
|
|
|
Post by Nick6475 on Apr 26, 2024 15:14:17 GMT -5
Just to add a few more names that the Giants could be potentially looking at today: DB: Cooper DeJean 6'0, 205lbs Jaden Hicks 6'2, 211lbs T.J. Tampa 6'1, 189lbs Cam Hart 6'3, 202lbs Tyler Nubin 6'1, 199lbs Dline: T'Vondre Sweat 6'4 366lbs Braden Friske 6'4 292lbs Kris Jenkins 6'3 299lbs Ruke Orhorhoro 6'4 294lbs RB: Trey Benson 6'0, 216lbs Jonathon Brooks 6'0 216lbs Oline: Dominick Puni 6'5, 313lbs Sedrick Van Pran-Granger 6'4, 298lbs Zak Zinter 6'6, 303lbs RB should not be on their list until Day 3 unless there is some crazy value or something. CB/S/DT - Defense is where the talent is in the second round. A lot of first round defensive players were pushed back because of the run on offense.
|
|